Can You Freeze Fish Pie?

Fish pie

Fish pie makes the perfect snack and meal for having friends, loved ones, and family over. It is a delicious meal that can be served for lunch or dinner, and they are mostly made fresh.

 You may be having friends and family over and want to cook ahead of time. So, you ask, “Can you freeze fish pie?” The simple answer is yes, you can: fish pies can stay up to 3 months in the freezer and 3 days in the fridge before your friends and family come over.

If you’re looking into long-term usage or freezing leftovers, be rest assured that you can freeze the fish pie for about 3 months. This article tells you what you need to know about freezing fish pie, defrosting it, and some handy tips.

What Is Fish Pie? 

Fish pie is a type of hearty delicacy loved by the United Kingdom and many other countries, but it originally comes from Scotland. It is similar to Shepherd’s pie and is often considered to be a casserole rather than a pie.

Fish pie, also known as fisherman’s pie, is prepared with flour, milk, butter, potatoes, onions, and of course, fish. Some may even contain prawns, cheese,

corns, and peas.

Bear in mind that if you want to freeze the fish pie, it is not advised to add ingredients like eggs and green peas.

What Are the Types of Fish Pies?

There are no types of fish pies but rather, there are different methods and recipes people use to prepare them in different countries, and cities.

How to Freeze Fish Pie

Freezing fish pie is easy once you follow these steps. To answer the question”Can you freeze fish pie?”, here’s a guide on how to go about it:

1. Allow It Cool

Before freezing fish pie, you need to let it cool off completely when it is brought out of the oven. You should never freeze fish pie immediately when it is out of the oven. Allow proper ventilation to circulate by placing the fish pie on the counter and ensuring it cools down before freezing.

2. Cut Fish Pie into Different Portions 

Cutting up or dividing fish pie is up to you based on the size of the fish pie you have. If you have fish pie in excess, cup it up into different small portions before you place them in the freezer. Divided pieces of fish pie make it easy to defrost and make use of at any time.

3. Place in Air-Tight Containers

Next, put your portioned fish pies into the air-tight containers. Ensure the container has a lid that closes very tightly.

4. Freeze Bag

Another safe alternative is the freezer bag. Put your portioned fish pies into the freezer bag and close the seal after pushing excess air out of the bag.

5. Label It

Lastly, record the storage date of the fish pie and ensure containers are closed tight and the freezer bags sealed. Go ahead and lay it down in the freezer for up to three months.

How Long Can You Freeze Fish Pie? 

You can freeze the fish pie for up to 3 months in the freezer. 

We recommend you don’t freeze fish pies that have ingredients such as boiled eggs and green peas in them, as they tend to go bad quickly even while in the freezer.

Also, use only airtight containers and seal freezer bags properly to prevent air from getting into them. If air comes in contact with fish pie, it quickly goes terribly bad and dries out the fish filling in it.

3 Tips For Freezing Fish Pie

Now, the question of whether can you freeze fish pie has been answered, here are a few tips to ensure you freeze it well:

TIP 1: Allow the fish pie to completely cool off before transferring it to containers or freezer bags.

TIP 2: Ensure you push out excess air from the freezer bag before sealing it firmly.

TIP 3: Ensure you use a clean and airtight container while freezing the fish pie.

How Do You Defrost Fish Pie?

Defrosting fish pie is pretty easy, all you need to do is take it out of the freezer overnight and transfer it to the refrigerator to allow it to defrost properly.

Fish pie gets frozen when it’s in the freezer for up to 3 months, so it would take a while to thaw.

You can also defrost fish pie and make it very tasty by garnishing the top with grated cheese to make it cheesy and creamy before placing it in the oven

Bear in mind that it takes 14–16 hours to properly defrost frozen fish pie.

How Can You Tell If Your Frozen Fish Pie Is Bad?

A frozen fish pie that is bad will have the following key indicators. If you notice any of this with your frozen fish pie, you should throw it out immediately.

  • A foul or off odor
  • An undesirable smell
  • An unpleasant and dull texture
  • A change in color
  • The appearance of bloat (swollen appearance) and molds

Can You Refreeze Fish Pie?

You should not refreeze your fish pie. It is advised against refreezing fish pie again. Fish pie that has been frozen before should not be put in the freezer to freeze again, as this will affect the texture, taste, and appearance of the pie.

Does Fish Pie Freeze Well?

In the event that fish pie is not made with boiled eggs and green peas, it freezes well and still holds its taste and texture as it would when freshly made.


In conclusion, to can you freeze fish pie, it can be frozen for up to 3 months and still retain its taste and texture only when properly stored in airtight containers and freezer bags.

I hope you have found this article informative. 

It may interest you to check out: Can you freeze soaked beans?


How to reheat fish pie?

To reheat fish pie, place it on a baking dish and bake it in the oven for about 20 minutes at 350°F.

Is it a good idea to freeze fish pie? 

Yes, it is always a good idea to freeze food products for a long time. Freezing fish pie is a good idea, as it stays in the freezer for 3 months and will taste just as fresh when defrosted and reheated to serve.

Can you freeze and reheat fish pie?

Yes, fish pie can be frozen and reheated straight in the oven or microwave. It takes 40–45 minutes to properly reheat frozen fish pie.

Can you make and freeze fish pie?

Fish pies can be made and frozen either before or after baking. The secret to freezing fish pies is to wrap them tightly in plastic wrap or cling film and store them in airtight containers or freezer bags. Fish pies can stay in the freezer for up to 3 months.

Can you freeze a potato topped fish pie?

Yes, you can freeze potato-topped fish pies. It freezes well in the freezer, but the color of the potato begins to change after some days, even when wrapped tightly.

How long will fish pie keep in the fridge?

Fish pie will keep in the fridge for 3-4 days before going bad.

Should you freeze fish pie before or after cooking?

It is better to freeze fish pie before baking rather than cook it. This way, you retain the taste and texture of the fish pie.

Why can’t you reheat fish pie?

Reheating fish pie overcooks it. If you do not mind, you can still reheat your fish pie, it still tastes as good as when you made it.

You may also like...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.